Wet n Wild Fergie On Edge Eyeliner vs M.A.C. Eye Kohl

Wet n Wild Fergie On Edge Eyeliner vs M.A.C. Eye Kohl.

(Left: W&W Midnight Girl Right: M.A.C. Smolder)

I've tried many eyeliners, but never found one that stayed all day until I found M.A.C. Eye Kohl in Smolder. It was love at first try! I knew I was going to have to replace it sooner or later because I can't sharpen it all the way down due to it getting chewed on my a dog & it being held by tape. I've bought I don't know how many different eyeliners in hopes that it will be a Smolder dupe. I found a coupon for $1 off of the new Wet n Wild Fergie line & figured I'd try that eyeliner since it looked creamy.

I think I found a pretty good dupe! The above photo shows how they look on. The W&W went on a little smoother then the M.A.C. did. They both went on dark, just how I like it to. I've used both on my waterline & on the inner rim of my eyelid. I would definitely recommend the Wet & Wild Ferige if you are looking for a cheaper alternative M.A.C.  I've heard that some people are comparing the Wet n Wild Fergie eyeliners to Urban Decay eyeliners, but I do not own any Urban Decay eyeliners, so I can't say. From the photos I've seen of Urban Decay, they do look similar. Hope you enjoyed this little review!